Equipment Appraisal Blog | Understanding Machinery Appraisals

Small business startup companies are popping up all the time, especially in newer industries such as cannabis and green energy, with consistently growing markets in biotech, construction, transportation, and IT. When you are involved in a new business startup, one of the priorities will likely be gaining access to working capital that will allow the business to get off the ground while investing in marketing and product development costs. Prospective investors may not rely solely on growth potential and an aggressive 5-year revenue forecast, therefore, collateralizing your recently acquired machinery and equipment will be your strongest option.

It is important for your startup to have the best, state of the art equipment on hand to begin operations, and whether you’ve already acquired these assets with your own investment funds, or you need the capital to purchase these critical components to your business, it is important to have detailed documentation available, so investors know what they have as tangible security.

Another important step will be to engage with an experienced, accredited machinery & equipment appraiser, who can independently support the value of your assets, on both a current basis and over that 5-year initial business plan you’ve put together. The appraiser will research the industry and develop opinions of value and useful life at various levels of the market while providing sources who are familiar with the manufacturing and resale of these types of machines.

This unbiased report will bolster confidence in any parties interested in taking the ride with you during the initial phases of your startup, including private investors, financial institutions, and your traditional banking relationships. While everyone knows your integrity and prior success in business, they will look to checks and balances with their decision-making, which an independent appraisal and industry review will satisfy.

In summary, ensure you work with an appraiser who has the expertise to provide a reliable, supportable report and takes the time to understand the full perspective of your goals, as you venture forth with your startup business.

There will come a time when your business or individual practice will need to appraise your used equipment. You may have a desire to sell and replace with newer machinery, refinance an existing inventory, seek new investors, settle an estate or transfer the assets of the business into a new entity. Depending on the type of equipment you own and operate, the amount of data available to review in the marketplace will range from overwhelming to non-existent

The most difficult step in the process of estimating used equipment value is making sense of the information you uncover, or lack thereof. For commonly resold assets such as construction equipment, trucks, and forklifts, you can find many similar comparisons in the market, however, the range in pricing can vary greatly. On the other hand, if you own a specialized piece of machinery that is customized to your specific operational needs, the resale market will not be the best place to search for information.

Equipment appraisers face these challenges every day, which is an excellent reason to consider engaging with an experienced, accredited valuation expert to assist in this effort. Over time, a seasoned appraiser will have developed sound strategies to reasonably determine value regardless of the type of assets you own. In the meantime, here are a few tips that can help you along the way:

Consider Multiple Sources

It’s not uncommon to see used equipment with the same year, make and model selling for vastly different prices in the marketplace at the same time. This could be due to any number of variables such as condition, hours/mileage, location, and recent refurbishments being completed. Oftentimes it's simply because dealers are testing the waters to see if they can obtain an inflated price given no immediate concern to sell. With all these factors at play, it is difficult to make sense of the varying data.

It’s important to investigate as many distinct sources as you believe reasonable and see if you can determine patterns that will allow you to better value your equipment.

Look at Multiple Perspectives

Given the inconsistent data found in the marketplace, alternate perspectives can bring the valuation process into better focus. Research what you paid for the equipment when you originally purchased it and consider the history of your usage and time since it was acquired. Determine what you believe to be a reasonable useful life for that equipment along with typical levels of depreciation that make sense in the context of your experiences as an owner-operator.

Finally, consider contacting your local equipment vendor to discuss what similar new equipment is selling for and gather their opinions on the current market.

Recognize the Specific Premise of Value You Need to Measure

Appraisers can provide estimates of value at different market levels, and your situation may fall into one or another, as you determine the need to sell. If you are in a hurry to turn your assets into cash, or just don’t have a lot of time to market your equipment, consider an Orderly or Forced Liquidation. If you are selling the assets as part of a larger transaction and the purchaser will be taking over some or all of your operation, then Fair Market Value is realistic, with consideration for applicable installation costs and related expenses to bring the equipment into operation.

In summary, it is always a good idea to consider bringing in an experienced appraiser to help you through this analysis who can develop an independent, unbiased process that will be supported by one or all of these methodologies.

When it has been determined by you and your equipment appraiser that a personal site visit will be part of the overall valuation effort, there will be a few things to plan for ahead of time as well as during the inspection to ensure an efficient and effective process. Here are the two most critical items to prepare before the appraiser arrives.

Preliminary Asset Records

For an appraiser to quote a valuation project, they will require an understanding of the asset content of your business. If there are only a handful of assets involved, creating an updated detailed listing of the equipment is feasible. If, however, a complete facility appraisal is in order, involving dozens of items, this option will be very time-consuming.

The most common source of documentation immediately available to you will likely come from your accounting department in the form of a capitalized asset depreciation record. This is a good place to start, however, many companies don’t detail all their equipment on this listing and tend to abbreviate descriptions. The three most important components the listing provides to the appraiser is the asset type, year acquired, and acquisition cost. Once on-site the appraiser can work with you during the inspection to fill in the remaining details and add unlisted equipment as necessary.

Scheduling the Site Visit Inspections

Depending on the reason the appraisal is needed, and the type of equipment being valued, the coordination of the inspection process can be a bit tricky.

If the company is being sold or acquired, employees may not be aware of the situation and may become concerned over why an appraiser is spending the day walking around the facility and taking a lot of photographs. There are a couple of options to consider in an effort to alleviate these concerns. The first is to provide an explanation to your employees that supports the reason an appraiser is on site. The most common ones I see used by business owners are that their insurance company or financial institution they utilize requires this as part of a general compliance audit.

The second option is to complete the inspections after hours or on a weekend when the facility is closed. This option also works well when transportation equipment is involved, such as delivery trucks and trailers. These assets are usually on the road during normal hours and will be stored on-site at night and on the weekends, creating a convenient time to complete the work in a timely fashion.

In summary, ensure you engage with an accredited, experienced appraiser, who is familiar with the steps involved and can assist and suggest the best way to move forward seamlessly. A seasoned machinery & equipment appraiser has been through this process many times and will become an asset to you and your business as you work through the sensitivities involved with an on-site appraisal.

Image source: Compactor. (2023, April 10). In Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compactor

Whether you own a company or are invested in the business as a principal, financial institution, or related third party, there may come a time when you need to liquidate some or all of the assets associated with the operation. Liquidation is a somewhat more ominous word for resale, typically where there is an urgency to sell the assets or that those individuals involved are not in the business of selling equipment.

As an appraiser, we are asked about this issue quite often, regarding the best approach and realistically what to expect when entering these unfamiliar waters. No single answer covers every situation, however, there are guidelines that can assist the reseller/liquidator who lacks any prior experience in this area.

If your business is reducing operations, or shutting down altogether, and the company owns considerable equipment and personal property, it is important to plan for a liquidation far in advance, where personnel remains available to aid in maintaining the condition of the equipment and can assist in showing the machinery to purchasers.

This will provide opportunities to arrange for the sale of your assets ahead of the actual closure, and allow buyers to preview them while still in operation. In an ideal world, you could effectively sell the assets as part of an ongoing business enterprise, however, if the company can’t sustain profitability, a more realistic scenario would be to locate competitors and other end users who will pay fair market value, based on the machinery remaining in good operable condition until sold.

If neither of these options is feasible, then a comprehensive liquidation effort should take place to realize an orderly (private sale) or forced (auction) liquidation value in a timely fashion.

Communication and timeliness are crucial in a liquidation effort, as the longer it takes to formulate a game plan and ultimately sell the assets, the less value will be realized. If equipment has been neglected for months and begins to fall into poor condition, buyers will no longer be comfortable offering a fair price. It is critical that the assets continue to be maintained, even after they cease operating. Hiring a mechanic to start and run the equipment on a weekly or bi-monthly basis is important to maintaining the condition.

Hiring a private reseller or an auction company who can coordinate the sale of the assets is a good option to complete the liquidation. An experienced third party will oversee the resale effort, while managing the logistics of the sale, including the security of the location, completing minor repairs, and creating a marketing campaign. This will increase the odds of a successful disposition where you pay a commission based on the sale price.

Regardless of the scenario you face, it is important to plan ahead and spend the time and resources needed to maintain the condition of the equipment, leading to a successful outcome in an otherwise difficult situation.

We have all seen or heard about the recent economic trends which have led to significant reductions to interest rates across broad spectrums of the consumer and business markets. The thought has likely crossed your mind to take advantage of these low rates when considering new equipment and personal property investments.

What about the existing capitalized assets you have owned for a few years and continue to work every day for your business? It might be time to look at refinancing options and take advantage of these low-interest rates before the markets start turning in the opposite direction.

Refinancing has several advantages to business owners who have considerable amounts of owned machinery & equipment. The two most significant are (a) the potential to lower your monthly debt payments where you have existing higher rate loans, and (b) the ability to access working capital based on the equity in your assets.

It is important to review your current debt structure and determine if existing loans can be restructured without a significant pre-payment penalty. Working with your present financial institutions should be a primary choice as they can often pre-approve your credit-based upon past transactions, and waive any penalties, provided you keep your business with them. Typically, pre-payment penalties expire after a couple of years, however, so be sure to read your loan contracts to better understand the terms and conditions.

The equity in your machinery &apm; equipment can be tapped if you have no or low debt obligations, and the cash can be used to inject working capital into your business, which then can be used for any number of new projects or growth plans. These assets have been capitalized and depreciated significantly on your books, however, their actual market value will likely be much higher.

To take advantage of this equity and support your assets’ current value, you should consider engaging an accredited, experienced machinery & equipment appraiser, who will complete a desktop or on-site valuation of your company’s tangible property. The appraiser will facilitate the process for you and suggest certain options that make the most sense in the context of your particular business and overall goals.

If you believe now is finally the time to start taking advantage of these favorable market conditions and low-interest rates, start taking these steps to make your financing plans a reality.