Equipment Appraisal Blog | Understanding Machinery Appraisals

We are often approached by clients who, in addition to needing a valuation, request a condition or damage assessment along with a repair estimate for their machinery and equipment. Professional appraisers come from varying career backgrounds; however, the majority do not have the ability to independently assess condition beyond a broad general visual inspection. Therefore, it is typically assumed that the associated values reflect normal operating conditions, unless there are specific details, including remediation costs, from the equipment owner or a qualified third party stating otherwise.

When a visual inspection is part of the valuation effort, either through a site visit or a review of photographs, it may be determined, based on general appearance, that certain assets need repair work or are out of service. In these instances, the appraiser can apply a reasonable condition penalty to account for this; however, without support of the specific repair costs needed, the adjustment will be very broad in nature, such as an estimated percentage deduction from the normal condition value.

It is important for the appraiser to point out these issues to their clients at the beginning of the project so there is no misunderstanding that occurs after the engagement is signed and the valuation work begins. If repair estimates are a critical component of the project, the appraiser can suggest that the client hire a technician to work in tandem with them to provide this assessment and expand the valuation analysis to take this into consideration.

The appraiser should be made aware if the equipment has experienced irregular maintenance scheduling or a long-term lack of use, as these issues can lead to a shortened useful life and significant repair costs to restore the machinery to normal operating condition. From the owner’s perspective, if the equipment is placed out of service for an extended period, it is important to store it in a protected environment, keep it clean of debris, and run it once a week, if possible, to properly maintain it. Otherwise, when it comes time to operate them again or sell in the open market, there might be costly unforeseen issues that crop up along the way.

In summary, as a business owner, investor, or other party in need of an independent valuation assessment, it is important to identify the most critical issues you are facing before engaging with an equipment appraiser, technician, or mechanic. If you are confident the equipment is in good condition, it makes sense to proceed immediately to the appraisal process. If you know the machinery needs to be assessed for damage and repair estimates, consider working first with an in-house maintenance manager, an outside technician, or even an insurance adjuster familiar with the assets to address these issues before hiring an appraisal expert.

Machinery and Equipment (M&E) appraisers need to consider and rely on various sources, while weighing the key components of both the sales comparison and cost approach, to fully flesh out a balanced estimate of value. Research is crucial; however, the ultimate analysis involves understanding all the pieces of data and how they fit together to effectively conclude on value.

It is important that an appraiser discern between available market and industry sources and differentiate which are reliable and which may not be. In some cases, you might believe there is a level of bias associated with certain data and opinions, such as a vendor or OEM that is advising that their equipment is second to none. A vital role of an accredited appraiser is to sift through the sum of the information and determine how best to put the right pieces together to arrive at a reasonable value.

An appraiser's level of experience is vital to deciphering this. Not only determining which sources appear most consistent and reasonable, but also making common-sense determinations on how the specific assets being valued would realistically trade in a secondary market based on their specifications.

There will be times when the equipment is very uncommon, with no secondary market information available to research. In other cases, the appraiser will have dozens of sources available to consider, with a wide array of differing price points. Each situation will present challenges in determining how best to conduct the analysis and arrive at a supportable assessment.

The purpose of the appraisal, as well as the definition of value being applied, will steer you to weigh the cost and market approaches a certain way. An appraiser's proper adjustment to each situation is based on their experience and understanding of the transactional picture and the scope of work for each assignment.

Keep in mind the conclusion of value is the appraiser’s determination, and theirs alone. The sources they rely upon are not responsible, nor are they the ones being paid to provide an independent estimate.

An opinion is always going to have some degree of subjectivity behind it, regardless of how much data supports it, and that’s okay. The more knowledge and experience an appraiser has, backed up by a reasonable amount of supporting data, the better the outcome will be.

Whether you’re a business owner, investor, bank, leasing company, partner, key employee, insurance provider, or just someone buying, selling, or donating equipment, there are several instances where understanding value will greatly assist you. Quite often, however, the fees associated with business and equipment appraisals get in the way of making a sound decision; however, when compared with the benefits you gain, you should not hesitate to pull the trigger.

Generally speaking, appraisal services are designed to assist in facilitating the closing of a transaction, whether business or personal, and are also utilized in the settlement of disputes. These can come in many forms:

Bank Financing and Leasing

The traditional process of working with banks, leasing companies, and similar financial institutions will require a review of underlying assets in order to collateralize and secure a loan or lease. They also become critical in the event of a default or end-of-lease buyout. Whether you’re the lender or borrower, it’s a “no-brainer” to obtain an independent, qualified valuation of the business and related collateral.

Private Equity Investment

A secondary source of capital for small businesses or in an outright acquisition, private investment will allow companies to expand their resources, promote growth, or transfer ownership. Both the buy and sell sides of these transactions need to support their opinions of value with an accredited appraisal.

Buying and Selling

In any outright purchase or sale of virtually anything valuable, those involved will want to have a formal appraisal report on hand to confirm the fairness of the deal. Successful negotiations are the cornerstone of good business practice. A third-party valuation will assist in the process.

Settling a Partner Buyout or a Divorce

Partners in life and in business may eventually fall out of favor with one another, and separation becomes inevitable. Negotiating a fair settlement will be made clearer with an updated valuation.

Reporting Requirements

Whether it’s for accounting, tax, or insurance purposes, an unbiased appraisal will not only come in handy but may be a requirement of the underlying authorities reviewing the transactions. Many of these relate to independent valuation and review.

In summary, once you determine the importance of valuation and how it will facilitate the process of managing and closing any transaction, don’t hesitate to find the most qualified, experienced appraisers and make the investment. It will not only assist you today but will come in handy down the road when a similar situation arises.

Machinery & Equipment valuation relies in part on understanding the new and used trade markets and developing an analysis that reasonably reflects what the subject assets being appraised would be worth in those markets. Before you even start to investigate this research, an early component of an M&E appraisal work effort involves the receipt of detailed data from the client that clearly identifies the machinery, including specifications and purchase history.

The additional perspective an appraiser receives by obtaining this data at the beginning of the engagement has many benefits. It saves the appraiser time by having them recreate this information themselves and allows them to price the valuation more competitively, given the time saved by performing this task themselves. Asset history provides specifics about the machinery being valued, which builds the foundation for the appraisal.

Every piece of equipment is different in its own way. The specifications, hours, mileage, usage factors, as well as upgrades and refurbishments completed at certain points in time, will all factor into the ultimate conclusion of value.

Knowing the original purchase price of the machinery, even if it was several years ago, will assist in reasonably verifying that the replacement cost estimates you determine are accurate. Appraisers cannot blindly assume all the independent market information they uncover is 100% bulletproof, as sources can be limited or inconsistent across multiple market sellers.

This is perhaps the biggest challenge in the equipment industry. Unlike business valuation, where databases and historical financial data are available and consistent in form, and real estate, where published comparable property resale data is more definitive, equipment market data can be erratic and full of gaps.

You will commonly see the same makes and models of equipment, with virtually identical specifications and usage, listed and selling for vastly different prices. The auction marketplace, which reflects billions of dollars of used equipment sales annually, experiences varying levels of demand, leading to less reliable data with a wide range of price points.

For every valuation assignment, consider performing a direct and/or indirect cost approach, which can be developed from the historical data provided by the client, as well as research into new equipment pricing in the market. This perspective will provide additional support and complement the market approach, ultimately determining a reasonable and supportable value for the equipment.

If you own a business looking to dispose of excess used equipment, or personally own property you no longer need, your first thought may be to resell it in the open market. This can be a difficult process with no guarantee of the price you will receive. Another effective option to consider is donating the assets to a local non-profit, such as a public school/university, hospital, research institute, charity, museum, or other tax-exempt organization.

Research options locally, or contact your high school and university to see if they would be interested in acquiring the used equipment for their educational programs, or refer you to a facility they know would be interested.

The benefits of this type of disposition are many. You have the obvious tax deduction, which offsets your income. You may also be accruing goodwill by helping the organization you’re donating to, as well as the individuals they support, by providing useful equipment they might not otherwise be able to afford. Scientific, medical, and technical research and educational institutions need resources to maintain and grow their foundations.

Before making the donation, make sure you check that the equipment is in good working order and clean it if necessary. Then create an itemized list of what you will be providing to the non-profit organization. This list will be very useful when filing your taxes and for valuing purposes.

If you are fairly certain the overall value of your donated machinery will exceed $5,000, you will need to obtain an appraisal to support the higher claim. The advantage of a donation appraisal is that the price level will be measured at fair market value, which is higher than any trade-in or liquidation price you would receive from potential buyers if you tried to sell on your own.

Look to engage with an experienced, accredited appraiser who is familiar with the type of assets you are donating. Equipment donation valuations are common, and the appraiser can provide the support needed to ensure you receive a reasonable and supportable value assessment.

Once the appraisal report is delivered, you will need to complete IRS Form 8283 for non-cash donations and have the appraiser review and attest to the reported value. You can submit this as part of your overall tax return.

Donations can also be made for unused inventory, such as spare parts and tools. Companies that produce excess finished goods can also donate these items using the same process. Equipment appraisers with experience in valuing inventory can work with you on these types of donations as well. In summary, before you decide to resell your excess used machinery, consider a donation as a more effective alternative.